Why We Can’t Get Enough: The Magnetic Pull of True Crime Podcasts

True crime podcasts have surged in popularity over the past decade, captivating millions of listeners worldwide. This phenomenon raises intriguing questions: What drives this fascination with true crime? Why do people find these stories so compelling? This article explores the psychological, social, and cultural factors contributing to the widespread appeal of true crime podcasts.

The true crime genre has a long history, but its presence in the podcasting world has grown exponentially since the release of “Serial” in 2014. “Serial” not only captivated audiences with its in-depth investigation into the case of Adnan Syed but also set a new standard for storytelling in the podcasting medium (Fleck). According to a Pew Research Center study, true crime is the most common topic among top-ranked podcasts, accounting for nearly a quarter of the most popular shows (Naseer and St. Aubin).

Humans have an innate curiosity about the darker aspects of life. True crime stories offer a safe way to explore these morbid curiosities without real-world consequences. The suspense and mystery involved in these stories engage listeners’ minds, providing a thrilling experience (Naseer and St. Aubin). True crime podcasts often delve into the lives of victims and perpetrators, offering listeners a chance to understand the human side of crime. This empathetic engagement allows listeners to connect with the stories on a deeper level, fostering a sense of compassion and understanding (Naseer and St. Aubin). Additionally, the complex narratives and investigative nature of true crime podcasts stimulate cognitive engagement. Listeners are drawn into the process of piecing together clues and forming their own theories, which can be intellectually satisfying (Fleck).

Psychologically, true crime podcasts tap into several key aspects of human nature. One significant factor is the concept of “morbid curiosity,” which refers to the fascination with the macabre and the grotesque. This curiosity is not merely a modern phenomenon but has historical roots, as humans have long been drawn to stories of crime and punishment (Nirtaut). True crime media allows individuals to explore these dark themes from a safe distance, providing a form of vicarious thrill without the direct consequences of real-life involvement.

Another psychological aspect is the role of empathy. True crime podcasts often humanize both victims and perpetrators, allowing listeners to empathize with their experiences and motivations. This empathetic engagement can lead to a deeper understanding of human behavior and the complexities of the criminal justice system (Keeler). Moreover, the narrative structure of these podcasts often mirrors that of detective fiction, where listeners are invited to solve the mystery alongside the host. This active engagement can be intellectually stimulating and emotionally rewarding (Keeler).

The psychological appeal of true crime podcasts also includes the concept of “fear management.” By listening to stories of crime and danger, individuals can confront their fears in a controlled environment. This process can help listeners feel more prepared and less vulnerable in their own lives (Vicary and Fraley). Additionally, true crime podcasts often provide a sense of justice and closure, as many episodes conclude with the resolution of a case. This resolution can be satisfying for listeners, reinforcing their belief in the effectiveness of the criminal justice system (Vicary and Fraley).

True crime podcasts create a sense of community among listeners. Online forums, social media groups, and fan clubs provide platforms for discussion and debate, allowing fans to share their thoughts and theories. This communal aspect enhances the overall experience and keeps listeners engaged (Podchaser). The portrayal of true crime in media has a significant impact on its popularity. Television shows, documentaries, and films often dramatize real-life crimes, creating a cultural backdrop that fuels interest in true crime podcasts. The success of shows like “Making a Murderer” and “Mindhunter” has further cemented true crime’s place in popular culture (UWM). Moreover, podcasts are easily accessible and can be consumed on the go, making them a convenient medium for storytelling. The episodic nature of true crime podcasts allows for in-depth exploration of cases over multiple episodes, keeping listeners hooked and coming back for more (Fleck).

While true crime podcasts offer entertainment and engagement, they also raise ethical questions. The sensationalization of real-life tragedies can be seen as exploitative, and the impact on victims’ families must be considered. Podcasters must navigate these ethical dilemmas carefully, balancing storytelling with respect for those affected by the crimes (UWM). Some podcasts have taken steps to address these concerns by including disclaimers, providing support resources for victims’ families, and ensuring accurate and respectful representation of the cases they cover (UWM).

The popularity of true crime podcasts can be attributed to a combination of psychological intrigue, social dynamics, and cultural influences. As this genre continues to evolve, it will be important for creators to remain mindful of the ethical implications of their work. True crime podcasts, with their unique blend of suspense, empathy, and community, will likely continue to captivate audiences for years to come. The ongoing fascination with true crime reflects broader societal interests in justice, morality, and the human condition, making it a genre that resonates deeply with listeners across the globe.

Works Cited

Fleck, Anna. “Chart: True Crime Podcasts Top the Charts.” Statista, 4 Oct. 2024, www.statista.com/chart/33189/top-ranked-podcast-genres-in-the-us/.

Keeler, Amanda. “True Crime Podcasts.” JSTOR, www.jstor.org/stable/10.3998/mpub.11435021.11.

Naseer, Sarah, and Christopher St. Aubin. “Who Listens to True Crime Podcasts in the U.S.?” Pew Research Center, 20 June 2023, www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/06/20/true-crime-podcasts-are-popular-in-the-us-particularly-among-women-and-those-with-less-formal-education/.

Nirtaut, Brianna. “True Crime Obsession: Analyzing the Effects of True Crime Media.” Indiana State University Honors Thesis, 6 May 2024, scholars.indstate.edu/bitstream/handle/10484/14638/annotated-GH401_True_Crime_Obsession_HonorsThesis_Nirtaut_2024.pdf?sequence=1.

Podchaser. “True Crime Podcast Statistics That Will Blow Your Mind.” Podchaser, 25 Mar. 2024, www.podchaser.com/articles/podcast-insights/true-crime-podcast-statistics-that-will-blow-your-mind.

UWM. “The Double-Edged Sword of True Crime Stories’ Popularity.” WUWM, 20 Jan. 2023, www.wuwm.com/2023-01-20/the-double-edged-sword-of-true-crime-stories-popularity-a-uwm-professor-explains.

Vicary, Amanda M., and R. Chris Fraley. “Captured by True Crime: Why Are Women Drawn to Tales of Rape, Murder, and Serial Killers?” Social Psychological and Personality Science, vol. 1, no. 1, 2010, pp. 81-86.

© Carrie S. Lemieux/CSLemieuxAuthor 2024. All rights reserved.